ERG Notes that ENRC Secures Landmark Victory as Court of Appeal Upholds Judgments Against SFO, Dechert LLP, and Neil Gerrard
Eurasian Resources Group (ERG), a leading diversified natural resources group headquartered in Luxembourg, which in late 2013 acquired the assets of Eurasian Natural Resources Corporation (ENRC), the former FTSE 100 company, notes that ENRC has successfully concluded a critical phase of its legal proceedings against the Serious Fraud Office (SFO), Dechert LLP, and its former partner, Neil Gerrard. In a decisive ruling handed down by the Court of Appeal on 2nd September, the SFO's application to challenge the High Court’s earlier findings was rejected, paving the way for a future damages trial.
Groundbreaking Legal Precedent
In May 2022, following an 11-week trial, Justice Waksman delivered a landmark judgment (the "Phase 1 Judgment") that uncovered "extraordinary" and "almost unimaginable" misconduct by Neil Gerrard, ENRC's former solicitor, alongside three former SFO officers, which was directly linked to the unlawful opening of a ten-year criminal investigation into ENRC.
These findings laid the foundation for a subsequent ruling in December 2023 (the "Phase 1A Judgment"), which concluded that the SFO would not have launched its decade-long criminal investigation into ENRC but for the unlawful conduct of its officers and Gerrard. As part of the Phase 1A proceedings, ENRC was awarded substantial damages in respect of legal fees incurred up to and including March 2013 and costs.
Court of Appeal Endorses Finality of Judgments
In April 2024, the SFO, Dechert, and Gerrard sought permission to appeal these rulings. However, the Court of Appeal, led by Lord Justice Males, refused their application, affirming that there was no basis for a successful appeal against the factual findings of the trial court. This decision is final and cannot be further reviewed or appealed. As a result, the damages and costs awarded to ENRC remain intact, with the proceedings now moving into "Phase 2" to determine further losses suffered by ENRC due to the SFO's investigation, which was abandoned in August 2023 without any charges, ending its decade-long corruption inquiry. ENRC had always denied any wrongdoing. A trial date for those Phase 2 proceedings has not yet been set.
Legal and Financial Implications
The Court of Appeal's refusal to allow the SFO to challenge the earlier judgments draws to a close any questions of the facts in the proceedings, and is definitive on the question of the SFO and Dechert’s liability for damages. The appellate court supported Justice Waksman's findings, highlighting the serious breaches committed by the SFO and the unlawful actions of Neil Gerrard and Dechert. The judgment confirms that the criminal investigation into ENRC would not have been launched without these unlawful breaches, and that the resulting damages and management losses suffered by ENRC were foreseeable and legally justified.
This ruling marks a significant milestone in ENRC's ongoing efforts to hold those responsible accountable for their actions. ENRC remains committed to pursuing full compensation for the substantial damages incurred and will continue to seek justice in the upcoming phases of this litigation.
Communiqués liés
ERG Notes that ENRC Secures Landmark Victory as Court of App...
Eurasian Resources Group (ERG), a leading diversified natural resources group he...
ERG announces a Pre-Export Finance Facility Agreement based ...
Eurasian Resources Group (“ERG”, “The Group”), a leading diversified nat...
ERG Africa’s Frontier hands over 30 solar boreholes to six...
On Saturday, 24 August 2024, Frontier SA, the DRC subsidiary of Eurasian Resourc...
The DRC Minister of Mines, H.E. Mr Kizito Pakabomba, visits ...
On Saturday, 17 August 2024, ERG Africa was honoured to welcome His Excellency (...
Eurasian Resources Group signs memoranda of understanding wi...
During a business forum at the “Central Asia plus Japan Dialogue”, Eurasian ...
ERG continues to diversify its cobalt sales, signs agreement...
Up to 15kt of sustainably produced cobalt, or around 75% of ERG’s Metalkol vol...
Il n'y a aucun résultat pour votre recherche